Arnet
On-line resources from the
American Studies Resources Centre at LJMU

Liverpool John Moores University

Letters from
New York
By Lenny Quart

Lenny has lived in New York for most of
his life, and here he presents a varied selection
of letters expressing his own
unique take on city life.
Lenny QuartAmerican Studies Today Online

Front Page

New for 2014

An Elite Liberal University
Going to an Elite School

2013

Glistening
A Victory in the Culture Wars?
An East River Island
A Plethora of Police Scandals
Facts and Intuitions
Exploring a Queens Neighborhood
The Bronx: For Better or Worse
The City in Flux

Archive

Brooklyn Writers
Whatever Happened to America's White Working Class?
Once More about Obama
Political takes
An ennui-free city
Comfort Food for the Literate
A Unique Street
Election aftermath
Back to Obama
Transit Follies
An Economically Beleaguered City
Oscar Tedium
Prose and poetry
A Painful Conclusion to 2008
A Celebration of Two Writers
The Political Process
Growing Up in New York
Oscars 2008
Celebrating the Forward
A Bohemian Oasis
Cafeterias
Back-to-the-Land
A Word from a Convention Demonstrator
Election Post Mortem
Sidney Lumet: New York Director
The New York Subway
Times Square: Past and Present
New York on the eve of 2005
A Cheer for Self-Doubt
The Working Poor
A Vale of Tears
Spike Lee's New Orleans
Hasidim in Brooklyn
Slavery in NYC
A Cornucopia of Stories
A Painter in the City
Altman's Oscar Night
Bob Dylan: American Icon
Brooklyn Changing
Diane Arbus
Political Theatre
The New York Post
Public Life
Surviving the Inner-City
Transit Strike
Three Political Takes
The Sixties Redux
Memorials and Oscars

Follow us on Twitter

Join Friends of the ASRC on Facebook

Join Friends of the ASRC on Facebook


 

An Elite Liberal University
Posted 23 January 2014

Wheeler Hall, U of California, Berkeley
Wheeler Hall, UC Berkeley

These are difficult times for American universities. Despite large tuition fee increases, resulting in students' staggering under debt, some colleges continue to face increasing expenses that they don't have the revenue to cover for much longer. One-third of all colleges and universities in the United States confront financial situations significantly weaker than before the recession. In fact, Moody's Investor Service states that the 2013 outlook for the higher education sector, including even elite research universities, is a negative one.

For public universities, the big challenge is that the states are getting out of the business of higher education. In 1987, the states kicked in about three quarters of what public colleges spent on education.  Today they contribute about half. The rest has to come from tuition, and the state colleges are raising tuition and cutting spending to deal with the problem. The cuts have hit students who come from lower and middle income families, and also resulted in staff layoffs. It's all part of balancing state budgets (in response to the recession) on the backs of those who are most dependent on social spending.
About three years ago, the great documentarian Frederick Wiseman (the director of such films as High School, Welfare, Public Housing) turned his camera on the great University of California at Berkeley. At Berkeley, like most of Wiseman's films, is an exploration of the structure of an institution, often one under social strain - as well as, in his words, “a look at a wide variety of human behavior.” At the time of filming, the university was enduring a profound economic crisis resulting from severe cutbacks in state-government funding, and was now massively dependent on non-public funds.

Wiseman's vérité film conveys the flow of daily life on this vast, green, beautifully maintained university.  He does not employ a narrator's voice-over, so the audience is not made aware of the camera's constant presence. Using this fly-on-the-wall style Wiseman focuses on classrooms, administrative meetings, public lectures, a PhD student working on bionic legs for disabled soldiers, theatrical performances, marching bands, and even the cleaning staff at work. He then shapes the film's point of view from editing 250 hours of footage he amassed. (The editing itself took 14 months.)

Berkeley is a liberal, elite public university, arguably on a par with Harvard, Columbia, Stanford, and Yale, and other bastions of talent and privilege, which it sees as its competition. Wiseman was given almost total access to the university, and the four-hour epic portrait he constructs - essentially a paean to this complex intellectual cornucopia of a university - is one that any Berkeley administrator would exult in.

Wiseman's film spends a lot of time observing meetings where administrators struggle with how to maintain excellence when faced with draconian state cuts. The talk goes on too long, and is not particularly stirring. But one is struck by their concern, as they try to both preserve a high level of scholarships for low-income students and to figure out how to help middle-income students whose families were hurt by the economic crisis. Also, the university's chancellor, Robert Birgeneau, is viewed in the film to be the kind of even-handed, sympathetic, reflective man any university would love to have in charge.

In At Berkeley Wiseman also moves from seminar to lecture hall, watching classes taught by professors who have mastery of their material, and know how to question and provoke responses from their students. The classes range from a seminar on Thoreau, to a history class on the significant role ordinary people play in bringing about social change, on to classes in the mysteries of the cosmos, and a lecture hall where Robert Reich (once Clinton's Secretary of Labor) talks in an informal, humane manner to students about how leadership demands a capacity for self-evaluation. I'm certain Berkeley must have some less effective classes, and less attentive, committed students, but Wiseman has chosen not to show them.

The roiling Berkeley of the sixties' Free Speech Movement and anti-Vietnam mass demonstrations no longer exists, but student protests still take place against the budget cuts. The speakers invoke the memory of Berkeley activism and the stirring FSM leader Mario Savio, and then take part in a library sit-in. However, their protest fails to involve the mass of students, who continue studying in the library or lounging on the lawn, detached from the action.

   Berkeley may no longer be a radical hotbed, but liberal tolerance and the transmission of a progressive critique of American society dominates its ethos. It's also a predominantly Asian and white university that is built on a strong sense of intellectual community, and Wiseman's portrait of Berkeley provides one of the strongest arguments for the support of public education.
Still, if the university is relatively racially diverse, African-American and Hispanic students are underrepresented. And some black students in the film speak of bearing the emotional brunt of feeling subtly rejected; or of carrying more “baggage” than other students, because they are always treated as representatives of the black community.

The university's goal is education committed to rational argumentation, passion, knowledge and discernment. It's what I spent a lifetime in the classroom trying to achieve. In the main, my undergraduate students at my CUNY branch were less articulate, prepared, and responsive than Berkeley's. But there were moments when it all came together -  and students would suddenly understand the more subtle meanings suggested by a film's images or a novel's metaphors - and, in general, grasp more of the complexity of the world. It's what an elite, richly textured Berkeley, and a less privileged, sparer CUNY do at their best: challenge students to realize as much of their intellectual potential as possible.