The organising principle of this
absorbing collection of essays is the assertion that to approach contemporary
American thought and culture viewing the events of 9/11 as a convenient break
with the past would be a mistake. The editors and contributors do not deny
that the trauma of 9/11 transformed aspects of government policy (such as the
2001 Patriot Act) and public debate (the resurgence of the rhetoric of civil
religion, for example), but they do insist that much of what characterises the
life of the United States at the present time has its roots in the 1990s in
particular, and indeed the various social, political and cultural strains that
have been in evidence for centuries.
Halliwell and Morley marshal a wide range of contributions into
three discrete sections. The first of these tackles politics, including pieces
from Dominic Sandbrook and Kevin Mattson nuancing the 'culture of consensus'
formulations familiar to those with a knowledge of 1950s America. Both suggest
that contemporary conservatives and liberals alike (the reds and the blues of
the 'culture wars') are actually defined as much by their similarities as by
their differences, not only in their stance on social issues such as abortion,
but also in their willingness to embrace what Mattson terms a 'new media
landscape that blur[s]... the line between news and opinion', resulting in the
employment of relativist views of truth in the pursuit of absolutist ends. Six
essays pertaining to issues of 'society' follow, tackling topics ranging from
the environment and technology to religion, medicine and globalisation. In the
most striking of these, Howard Brick shows how any conception of America's
place in a globalised world must take into account the country's enduring
uncertainty over the desirability of a culture that either looks inward or
appeals in cosmopolitan language to the rest of the world. The essay also
reminds us that globalisation is a process that both 'integrate[s]' and
'fracture[s]' and that the United States will continue to struggle with
balancing supranational problems and internal issues of political
self-determination. The collection's final section outlines the cultural
currents flowing through contemporary American life, ranging over literature,
animated films and television and photography in the digital age. Here the
emphasis is on the way in which certain longstanding narratives in American
culture (the captivity narrative, Life founder Henry Luce's notion of an
'American Century') have been problematised by technological innovation and the
implications of waging war against the abstraction of 'terror'. In her piece,
Catherine Morley describes how fiction writers have been forced to imagine
'counternarratives' in order to 'wrestle [back] power from the terrorist' and
comprehend America's changed place in the world. At the same time, Morley also
locates two of post-9/11 American fiction's key themes - the decline of the
family and the 'de-establishment' of the middle-class - in the pre-9/11 context
of the 90s when consumer debt rose dramatically.
The eighteen essays in this volume
provide a stimulating starting point in any consideration of contemporary
American thought and culture with the important intellectual contributions of
figures such as Samuel Huntington, Francis Fukuyama and Thomas Friedman all
being absorbed into the analyses in interesting ways. It's a shame that the
book's U.K. publication pre-dated Barack Obama's election as president as this
renders some of the commentary regarding, for example, the persistence of a
widespread Republican voting bloc and the poverty of much political rhetoric in
the U.S. as already out of date. However, such claims run the risk of positing
Obama's victory as another historical caesura and, as American Thought and
Culture in the 21st Century clearly demonstrates, such an
approach entails its own risks.